Because most of the 10 studies suggested a different time or day, there is sort of a consensus that Tuesdays, Thursdays, and possibly Wednesdays are the best days to send email marketing messages, but that’s only if you look at many studies, using each one as a data point.
So problem solved, right? The best day for email marketing is on, um, Tuesdays, right?
Not really. I hate to tell you this, but 10 data points do not make for a statistically valid conclusion. And I can easily trot out another bunch of studies that would further skew those conclusions.
There are more answers to which day of the week is best to send marketing emails on than there are days of the week.
Remember how the data above generally showed that weekdays are best? Well, here’s Dan Zarrella’s research. It shows that the best days for email marketing are weekends. And here are more examples of how these results are spread all over the map (and the week):
SEOPressor found that, although there are high open- and click-through rates on Saturdays and Sundays, their research left them confident in saying , “… overall, Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays are likely the most successful days for sending your email out to subscribers.”
Omnisend analyzed roughly 791 million emails earlier this year. They found that the best day for email opens was Wednesday, and the best day for clicks was Sunday. But Thursday came in second for both opens and clicks. (To their credit, SEOPressor and Omnisend both recommend testing which day is best to send for yourself.)
Eventbrite found that Wednesday was the best day for email marketing in the US for event marketers. In the UK, it was Tuesday. But when they broke their data down by category, it was all over the map, as you can see below.
So is there a trend of the best time to send an email? Yes. It seems to be Tuesdays. Sort of.
So should you just send your marketing emails out on Tuesdays?
Here’s why: Your company probably did not participate in any of those studies. Those studies are all well and good, but those other companies’ results are not yours.
That’s hardly the only problem here, too. These studies also determine “the best” day to send based on clicks and opens. That’s a nice starter way to measure success with your emails, but what matters is sales ― revenue generated. None of these studies track that.
Because all those studies and tests treat all the list’s subscribers as if they were the same.
What Is the Best Time to Send an Email?
Not only do you have to take the day of the week into account, but it is also important to consider the best time of day to send an email campaign. A recent blog by Wordstream suggested that it is usually better to send during the daytime and general guidance would be to send between 9-11 am or 1-3 pm. But even in their own testing, they found that it strayed from these best practices.
In other compiled studies, it was found that the best time of day to send an email campaign was highly dependent on the day of week you’re sending out your emails. On Tuesday’s you may want to send at 10am, but on Thursday’s at 8pm.
All Email Subscribers Are Not the Same
At the end of the day, your subscribers don’t all have the same priorities, the same reading habits, the same device habits. Heck, if you’re doing your job as an email marketer, your subscribers should not even be getting the same message all the time. You should be segmenting your subscribers based on their interests and what you have to say to them.
You can, could, and even should be personalizing the emails they get ― and not just with their names, either. You could be using dynamic content to serve up the pieces of content they’re most likely to enjoy.
The Amazingly Effective Email Marketing Automation Guide
The way those subscribers react to your emails isn’t based on only their interests, either. How they respond depends on where they are in the world ― what time zone they’re in. One subscriber’s 9 am on the East Coast is another’s 6 am on the West Coast. That affects how likely they are to open your emails.
To really be cutting-edge now, you need to be sending your subscribers emails when they’re most likely to open them. And that magic time is different for each subscriber. But that personalized timing is hardly the final frontier. Even if you could do the perfect email marketing study of when it would be best to send to your personal list, you’d still be missing out. And missing out big time.
What we need now to succeed in this marketplace goes way beyond basic personalization and segmentation. We need to be able to personalize each customer’s email messaging based on everything listed below:
when they’re most likely to open;
what content format they’re most likely to respond to;
which buyer persona they fit into;
what their past buyer behavior or content consumption was;
where they are in the buyer’s journey;
who their primary sales contact is, or who their primary customer service contact is;
what their last sales or customer service contact was; and
if they’re more likely to respond to a message via a channel other than email (like via social media, or postal mail, or even a wacky old-school phone call).
The list could go on … but I think you get the idea.
So let’s take this to the next level.
Because even if you modeled an ideal buyer’s journey based on all of those parameters, you still wouldn’t have an ideal system.
Because every buyer is different.
Every Email Subscriber Is Different ― and Every Buyer’s Journey Is Different, Too
The paths your buyers are taking through their journeys to become customers are varied. Think of those journeys more like a crazy web (or maybe even a neural net) than as a tidy, well-defined path through a park. In fact, if you really wanted to build the perfect messaging system, you’d have to take all the data from every single subscriber and every interaction all your subscribers had had, then use computers to build models based in part on that behavior and in part on whatever criteria you set.
Then you’d have to use machine learning (a type of artificial intelligence) to set the whole thing up so the computer could make educated guesses for what to send each individual subscriber every time, drawing from what the computer would know about all past subscribers’ behavior, and about each particular subscriber’s behavior.
That’d be a heck of a thing, right?
We thought so.
And we thought it would be so cool, and such a game-changer, that we invested in making it.
Segmentation may not personalize for each individual subscriber, but it makes sense when you want to send an email to everyone in a particular group. The algorithm that runs Adaptive Journeys can suggest the best ways to segment your list, based on data or behavior.
Forms are critical micro-conversions along the buyer’s journey. Our system auto-magically optimizes them based on past answers and behavior.
The algorithm predicts the ideal time to send a message ― not to your entire list, but to each individual subscriber.
Get ready to bring your lead scoring into the 21st century. Adaptive scoring lets you automate your scoring based on a matrix of parameters.
We aren’t limited to just email. Messages can also be sent via custom web page, mobile, or via social media.
So the next time somebody asks you the best day to send an email to their subscribers, you can respond: “To which subscriber, for which type of message? Oh yeah ― and are you sure email would be the best channel for that?”
Adaptive Journeys can help them find the answers to these questions.
The Amazingly Effective Email Marketing Automation Guide